Apparently GameStop/EB stores have been receiving full Super Mario Galaxy discs to use as in-store demos. On the store systems, gameplay is restricted to 10 minutes, but the restriction is not inherent to the disc ... which means that if an unscrupulous EB employee were to sneak off with the disc and rip it, he or she could then make the full game available online.
Which is exactly what has happened. Soon, people who wouldn't buy the game anyway will be playing it for free, weeks before its release. We don't know where it's available, and we're not going to look, and neither should you. Of course, the dumped game will only work for chipped Wiis.
For some reason, we can't muster up the expected level of outrage for this egregious crime. Sure, a guy broke the law, but very few people will actually download this, and we're pretty sure that Super Mario Galaxy will do a nice amount of business. Besides, you totally don't get a free coin when you steal the game. Right?
Super Mario Galaxy floating freely into space
Posted Oct 25th 2007 6:00PM by JC Fletcher
Filed under: News
Tags: gamestop, piracy, super-mario-galaxy
Related Headlines
- Yarr! New homebrew program runs DVD game backups (27 days ago - 34 Comments)
- Wii systems getting rooms at Marriott hotels (11 days ago - 2 Comments)
- Top 5: Where Do They Go Now? (34 days ago - 36 Comments)
- Gamestop VP says Wii supply will be 'much, much better' this holiday (23 days ago - 2 Comments)
- Link's Price Slashing (32 days ago - 13 Comments)














Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-25-2007 @ 6:09PM
Mr Khan said...
Well, if it means someone'll play it and have a guide ready to post on Gamefaqs by the time it comes out so i don't have to spend $15-20 on a guide, more power to 'em (even though i don't encourage this, modchips should only be for breaking region locks)
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 6:10PM
CJC said...
Damn, that was fast. The Internet is terrifying in so many different ways.
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 6:13PM
Collin said...
This is kind of sad. I wish people wouldn't steal games as it hurts the future of getting other great games made. I know Nintendo isn't gonna go out of business over a few missing sales but still. Smaller companies may and they often bring us the best games. I guess it will never stop and luckily most people aren't going to mod their consoles to play them so it is somewhat contained. Still kinda bums me out.
Want free Wii games? Click here for more info.
http://www.prizerebel.com/index.php?r=40950
No money or credit card needed, just time to do online surveys!!
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 6:16PM
JC Fletcher said...
Mr Khan = guide pirate CONFIRMED
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 6:29PM
Mr Khan said...
Eh, i'd probably end up buying this guide anyway. These completion-centered games usually merit a guide (like main Super Mario games, Zelda, and Metroid titles)
Although not having to pay monies is tempting
Although i hope its a Prima guide, they do such excellent work (they're almost worth buying for the interior art alone)
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 6:35PM
Shogan said...
I don't think this will hurt Nintendo in any real way. Sure the bootleg is out there, but how many people have modded Wii's anyway?
And doesn't Nintendo's updates disable the hacked Wiis anyway? I think Nintendo looked at the PSP and Sony's attempt at stopping hackers and made a smart move. The updates we get for the Wii usually have some great additional content added, and even occasional added functionality for the games and the system. It's an improvement on the Wii overall, which is a big enough incentive to click that upgrade button.
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 7:10PM
vidGuy said...
Yeah, I read yesterday about a kid that got one from the demo machine, took it home, and is trying to beat it before its official release.
Doesn't matter to me, I'll be buying it in a few weeks and enjoying it for years.
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 7:29PM
David W. said...
So this is kinda off-topic...but how long until the other stores get to have Wii demo units?
I work electronics at Target...and I'm pretty sure our "demo wii" which I assumed was hollow and just there to show people what it looks like...is real...it seems to be the correct weight, and from what I can see, the components are there *shrugs*
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 8:07PM
JC Fletcher said...
Oh, I was just messing with you, Mr Khan. Free game guides are wonderful!
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 8:51PM
bleh said...
Get over it. You all got your Wiis hand-delivered to you at no charge. Bloggers are in no position to lecture gamers about how they obtain games.
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 8:52PM
Adam O'Neill said...
I second the chipping for region-lock purposes (I live in Australia) but I'm not a big fan of piracy, except for music but that's a beef I have with the industry (adapt or die asshats).
Very sad that people show such contempt for an industry that clearly means something to them (otherwise why would they pirate at all).
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 9:53PM
Lee said...
I usually don't care when this sort of things happens... but with Mario Galaxy, it breaks my heart. =(
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 9:58PM
Just_a_guy said...
um..... do I even care?
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 10:59PM
Jeremy said...
I don't believe in mod chips but software mods can be really great.
Reply
10-25-2007 @ 11:19PM
SpecialGuestStar said...
Copying isn't stealing, Newspeak-peons.
The Internet's existence and function wrt copying IP has been well-known for a full decade now. Maybe they should just release the game when it's ready instead of adding artificial marketing delays, and it wouldn't be so much of a problem.
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 1:15AM
ZagZagovich said...
AWESOME!
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 6:18AM
spamslurpee said...
Seriously, with the stupid region locking to divide and control markets, delaying releases differently in some countries to tweak sales, all that is sure to tick people off. All they have to do is add online-gameplay to the games and piracy would be marginal, but that appears to be sooo hard with the Wii..
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 9:41AM
vidGuy said...
"Copying isn't stealing, Newspeak-peons."
While U.S. copyright law allows some fair use, such as for educational purposes or if you legally own the original work, copying anything which you did not legally obtain IS stealing in the U.S. Copying an MP3 file from the internet without purchasing the work in some other format is stealing, whereas copying the song from a CD you bought is not.
In this case, copying the disc is stealing because it was not legally obtained.
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 10:00AM
vidGuy said...
"Bloggers are in no position to lecture gamers about how they obtain games."
Except, you know, the company sends them the game in exchange for coverage (a legal method of obtaining the game) whereas piracy is stealing (illegal).
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 10:16AM
JC Fletcher said...
Copyright infringement is illegal (and, might I add, a practice that Wii Fanboy frowns upon!!!!), but that doesn't mean it's the same thing as stealing. I was using the term pretty dismissively in the post!
And don't make assumptions about where we get our games. I guarantee you there will be no free copy of Mario Galaxy for me. We have to buy our own games just like anyone else, except we make less money.
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 1:00PM
vidGuy said...
@JC,
Would you mind explaining how copyright infringement isn't stealing? I'm not arguing here, just interested since I will be entering law school for Intellectual Property next fall. I'm not quite sure how anyone would think that taking something of value without paying isn't stealing under the word of the law.
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 2:30PM
Magili said...
@ vidGuy,
Under US law, copyright infringement is not equal to stealing (theft) because it does not deprive the original owner full use to the object, or through possession the new "owner" gains the full copyrights to that object. For example, when a bike/car is stolen, the original owner can no longer use that property. This is something that the US Supreme Court has stated in the past. But just because infringement doesn't equal stealing doesn't mean that it's ok.
I want game companies to make more games, so I am sad that some are pirating Mario Galaxy, but it is also true that not many people have modded Wiis, so it should only affect a small percentage of people.
I love my games, but as a whole, copyright laws have gotten out of control. Mainly with music/movies.
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 3:37PM
vidGuy said...
That's true, Magili. Although I'd agree that copyright infringement shouldn't fall under theft (especially since it's usually handled as a civil suit rather than criminal charges), I was thinking of the layman's use of the word "stealing". Considering that most people do not understand the proper definition of words like "assault", "accosting", and even "murder", I didn't expect that argument.
I expected someone to justify it with the try-before-you-buy argument ;)
Reply
10-26-2007 @ 6:24PM
JC Fletcher said...
Oh, that's awesome that you're going to law school for IP, vidGuy. I'm nervous for anyone going into any kind of graduate school, but that's such an interesting area of law, especially these days.
Reply
10-27-2007 @ 1:24AM
vidGuy said...
Thanks for the support, JC. Not trying to sound snobbish here, I'm just really interested in it after being a teen during Napster's heyday and doing my undergrad in Computer Investigations.
Anyway, Galaxy FTW! I'm bummed we are missing out on Brawl this holiday but if the previews are to be believed this true successor to Mario 64 is going to be keeping me mighty busy! ;)
Reply