Do the prices of Virtual Console games seem high to you? They do to us, as well, but it turns out that they may not be as bad a deal as they look. JJ Hendricks compared some recent secondhand sale prices for vintage games with their VC price, and found that for almost every VC system, you save money by buying the virtual version -- if you buy every game. With the exception of the NES, the aggregate cost of every VC game for each system was lower than the cost of physical copies. In the case of the Turbografx-16, the difference is especially dramatic: when calculating the difference between total cost (which was already $883 in favor of the Virtual Console), JJ couldn't find a recent price for the super-rare Dynastic Hero. One of those just ended on eBay for an initial bid of $350.Of course, with the Virtual Console, you don't get a physical item. That may be important to you, and used to be for us, but these days, with limited storage space and unlimited desire for things, we find it slightly distasteful when something takes up space. In that regard, virtual copies are a bonus for us.
Where this really falls apart is buying individual games. You're unlikely to buy every game using either method, and while you save on something like Shining Force ($31.99 out in the real world vs. $8) you lose on more common stuff like Soccer (which you shouldn't be buying anyway). But the point stands that the Virtual Console pricing is not ... one hundred percent terrible.
Of course, you could always just use this article as a guide to which games to buy on the VC and which to buy from eBay. Be a smart shopper!
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-01-2008 @ 10:21AM
chad said...
the biggest reason i like the physical copy is that i can use the actual controller for which the game was designed. this is especially true for me with n64 games. i'd really like to try sin and punishment with the proper controller.
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 10:41AM
JacKal said...
The virtual console prices don't bother me a bit. Everyone complains but I really love it. I'm not paying just for the game, I'm also paying for the convienience. It's really important to me. I can download any game available on the VC whenever I want if I don't have it already. I can load up any one of these games across 6 different systems immediately, and put them down just as quick and get back to the real world (don't have to get up, turn off the console, put away the controllers; just turn off the wii from the wireless wiimote and jet). Then there are the save states (for some games the replay value alone is seeing how it is with save states it might not have had possible before), playing on my tv (not my computer screen with some emulator)... and all of that one from tiny little console. If I only really repeatedly play two separate neo-geo games for instance, I don't need to hook up a freaking neo-geo each time I want to play one (and then put it away when I've got to hook something else up). I don't have the space for 6 consoles anymore like I used to when I was a kid. If you count the wii+gamecube, then technically this tiny console is capable of 8 different systems. I have other things in my entertainment center and I still love these vintage games. All of these things are incredibly valuable to me personally, so I can say for myself at least that the prices are just fine to me, and comparing to just the physical value of finding a random copy of the same game isn't really the same to me.
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 10:46AM
Matthew McNutt said...
I guess I haven't really had a problem with the pricing. Five bucks for a game I've loved for years and the convenience of being able to have it all on one system? It costs more to see a movie, and almost that much to rent a dvd, so to me it's not that bad. Even the $10 games might seem a little steep at first glance, but you don't have to buy every game. I love the convenience; on a snow day when my kids are cooped up inside and we can't get out to get anything, I can download a new game and keep them entertained for a while. Besides, paying $2 for a used, twenty year old cartridge that might give out or be undependable doesn't really seem like saving all that much money to me!
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 11:47AM
Sisyphus said...
The pricing makes me cringe a little bit. Mostly the 1000 points for N64 games. I love having my SNES, TG-16 and NES games again. My Turbo Duo still works, but its more of a hassle to break out and setup than just playing on my wii. Longer controller cables too. :) I have Super Mario 2, 3 and World, as well as Air Zonk, Bonk's Revenge, Bonk 3, Bomberman and the SNES Zelda game.
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 2:22PM
antho said...
How much a game costs used is irrelevant. VC games are overpriced. It costs nintendo and third parties next to nothing to offer them as a download. They make mad profits (probably at least 90%) on old games that most of us have already paid for once--sometimes twice if the title in question is available on GBA or DS!
I’ve stopped buying VC titles unless it is something that I missed the first time around and know I really want to play.
Bring on the new content, I'm sure I'll be going through lots of Wii-Points once WiiWare titles start arriving.
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 2:58PM
hvnlysoldr said...
I wonder when he'll be finished with his follow-up article if the prices of used carts went up or down when they ended up on VC.
Reply
2-01-2008 @ 4:02PM
HellsHammer said...
This is something I've been worried about for a while, as I collect 'physical' versions of video games.
I've still got Zelda 1, 2, TttP, and Oot Complete in the boxes...I imagine that I'm going to be a little bummed. I can't even see myself paying ebay prices with certain VC games available to me.
2-01-2008 @ 6:38PM
Jared said...
I think they're a little expensive. I've blown $60 thus far, and I have some regret on about $15 of that. I still have an N64, but Wave Race 64 used to go for $7 used at local game stores, and now it's over $10 (including shipping), plus waiting to get it off eBay. There has been some positive, with potential for even more positive. Some carts that were crazy expensive to shell out for are now available for pretty cheap. However, they need to make the more expensive titles, especially N64 ones like Bust-a-Move 99 and Cruis'n Exotica available. If I could get those for cheap, it'd hurt a little less to plunk down for those old games.
Reply
2-02-2008 @ 8:08AM
Almadi said...
Two points (Wii Points) JC:
1- The reason the actual games are expensive in the first place is their rarity. A crappy neogeo game an go up to $12000, while a great N64 game like Mario 64, you can get brand new for $5. So the rarity thing goes away with the unlimited supply in virtual form.
2- If you buy said rare game, you can still sell it at even a higher price later. with the VC games, you are stuck with them. Oh how I wish I can resell my Fatal Fury VC purchase for even 200 Wii points.
oh, and if they don't release Samurai Showdown this month on the VC, I will sell my Wii and get the true economic VC machine (the PSP).
But for now, I'll try to finish NMH.
Reply